Circumcision, is it really necessary?

One of the first decisions you make as the parent of a boy is whether or not to circumcise. Circumcision has medical, social and emotional considerations for parents of infant boys. Of course, having a baby of either gender brings with it many decisions. From the moment that second pink line appears you are a parent. Some parenting choices can be fun, like what color to paint the nursery. Other choices require more research and discussion between the mother and her partner including whether or not to circumcise.

For centuries, the only reason for circumcision was a religious one. Non-faith based circumcision began with the Victorians during the mid-to-late 1800s. They believed that removing the foreskin would reduce the male’s urge to masturbate.

The decision to circumcise may be guided by your religious beliefs. Both Jews and Muslims circumcise as part of religious rites. The decision not to circumcise, however, may be one that you never considered. “Aren’t most boys circumcised? Isn’t it cleaner? Why wouldn’t I want my son to look like his father and all the other boys in the locker room?” While these myths are prevalent in the United States and other parts of the Western world, the facts of circumcision tell a significantly different story.

Circumcision of male infants is not a medically necessary procedure; it is plastic surgery for the penis. The practice of circumcision began in ancient Egypt, according to Desmond Morris in his book Babywatching. The ancient Egyptians believed that the snake shedding its skin was undergoing a rebirth and, thus, became immortal. They reasoned that if humans followed suit they, too, would attain immortality. The foreskin was equated to the snakeskin, and the practice of circumcision was begun.

For centuries, the only reason for circumcision was a religious one. Non-faith based circumcision began with the Victorians during the mid-to-late 1800s. They believed that removing the foreskin would reduce the male’s urge to masturbate. From that starting point, circumcision has been deemed by various groups to be more hygienic and credited as a preventative measure for diseases from chlamydia to HIV. In reality, removing the foreskin accomplishes none of these assertions and could result in more serious problems.

The foreskin has several known functions, even in modern times. While some people suggest that its use has gone the way of the appendix, in reality the foreskin aids in the sexual health and enjoyment of men. The foreskin is a protective cover for the penis that needs no special care. At birth, the foreskin is attached to the head of the penis, much like fingernails are attached to the end of your fingers. It will remain attached until the boy is about ten years old. Premature retraction of the foreskin can lead to an increased chance of infection.

Early life functions of the foreskin are to help in the proper development of the penile glans and to protect the glans from feces and urine-based ammonia in diapers. Throughout the man’s life, the foreskin continues to protect the glans from friction and abrasion and keeps it lubricated and moisturized by coating it in a waxy, protective substance. When the man becomes sexually active, the foreskin allows sufficient skin to cover an erection by unfolding and aids in penetration by reducing friction and chafing. The foreskin is highly sensitive and is, in fact, an erogenous tissue rich with erogenous receptors. For his partner, the foreskin contacts and stimulates the female’s G-spot.

There are additional considerations when deciding upon whether your male infant will undergo circumcision. As with any medical procedure, there are complications presented by the choice to circumcise. In March 1999, the American Academy of Pediatrics concluded that any potential medical benefits are not significant, and the AAP no longer recommends circumcision as a routine procedure. Prior to consenting to a circumcision, the mother must sign a consent form outlining the risks of the procedure. These risks include hemorrhage (in about 2% of cases), infection, deformity, scarring, permanent bowing of the penis (chordee), and urinary retention from swelling, among other concerns, including loss of the penis. Though rare, death occurs in approximately 1 of every 5000 circumcisions. Many circumcisions are done without the use of anesthetic, but if anesthesia is used, there are additional complications presented by using anesthetic drugs on an infant.

Despite the American perception, circumcision is not a worldwide practice. Eighty-two percent (82%) of the world’s male population is intact. That leaves the 18% of circumcised men in the minority. Even in the U.S. circumcision rates are declining.

Starting around World War II, rates of circumcised boys increased steeply as American births were moved from the home into the hospitals. Rates of U.S. circumcisions reached a plateau during the late 1980s. With the new century, rates of circumcision began a slow decline. In the latest census reports, from 2003, approximately 55% of American newborn boys are circumcised. Some sources believe that American circumcision rates will decrease steadily over the next generation and return to the pre-WWII ratio of approximately 1 of every 4 boys being circumcised.

Whether or not to circumcise is a decision that must be made with concern for immediate and future implications for the male child. As more parents become aware of the choices they have in labor and birth, more parents are also making the decision not to circumcise.

For more information on circumcision, visit By Jennifer Harris ( ©2006 for EDITOR’S NOTE: I personally feel that every mother who decides to circumcise their son should watch this video, with sound, in it’s entirety.


Ben Earwicker
Garrison Photography


  1. The official death rate from routine infant circumcision in the USA is 1 in 500,000, not 1 in 5000. The true death rate is unknown, because doctors and hospitals conspire to conceal the fact that the true ultimate cause of a baby’s death was its routine circumcision, which would trigger liability for malpractice.

    American circ rates maxed out in the 1970s, and began to decline in the 1980s. We do not know the true circ rate, because Ministries of Health around the world count only maternity ward circumcisions, and not those done to children as outpatients in doctor’s offices.

    Routine circumcision became an accepted practice among the American urban middle class as early as 1900. Historians have uncovered a lot about how John Harvey Kellogg and others of his ilk banged the drum for circumcision in the late 19th century. We know much less about what influenced the typical middle class mother of the era. During the crucial period 1920-40, very little was published about routine circumcision, even though the practice was already common and becoming more so. The first half of the 20th century was a period that witnessed a quiet revolution in attitudes towards sex and the intimate body. Just look at the evolution in women’s bathing attire between 1910 and 1960. Or the rise in the awareness and acceptability of contraception. Or the rising commercial exploitation of male sexual desire, and the decline of conventional prostitution. Just how the rise of routine circumcision fits into this wider story of sex in the 20th century, has yet to be written.

    The circumcision rate in the 1920s was at least 50%, and was probably already 90%+ among urban middle class Protestants. In the USA, the circumcised penis used to be a sort of human “cattle brand,” signalling that a man was born to educated middle class parents. A little appreciated factor behind the rise in American circumcision was barracks life during the world wars and the Korean conflict. Every day in the showers, enlisted men from urban working class and rural redneck backgrounds could see that men from comfortable urban backgrounds had bald penises. Thus circumcision came to be seen as cool by men from less sophisticated families.

    Mommy blogs such as this one go lightly over the sexual advantages of the natural penis, and this post is no exception. But I remind readers that there is an ample and growing body of anecdotal evidence that routine infant circumcision can detract from adult sexual pleasure and functionality, and can result in men who are sexually damaged for life. The full story here constitutes an unwritten chapter in the journey of our species towards sexual discovery and awareness. There is no User’s Manual for the human body, purchasable at any bookstore; we have to research, write, and revise that manual, one chapter at a time.

  2. HI I m 51 yrs old and ” uncut ” I ve lately been uncumfortable [? ] when I have an erection. It just feels like the skin is too tight . This made me believe that I needed to be ” cut ‘ . I went without sex and was not interested in masturbation for a long time , as it turns out a medication I am on caused low testestrone. I have started shots to bring the levels back up[ no pun ] Now I am wondering if for some reason I need to be circumsized, did the skin shrink ? Due to lack of having regular erections for a period of time ?? I can still bring the foreskin back all the way with no discomfort, but somthing just does not feel right. Could anyone relate ? or suggeset somthing? My sex drive is in OVERDRIVE , but even to mastubate is just not the same , not comfortable . Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

  3. I have struggled with this my whole life ..Thought I was the only kid in the locker room with an ABNORMAL penis… and now wonder if that has somthing to do with never being married or comfortable being naked in front of ANYONE.. A quick explanation at a young age I feal would have made A big difference. 50 years ago we didn t talk so openly about these things… Just my opinion.. But would love to hear from anyone that may have the same fealings ? THANKS Fred



  1. Are Breastfeeding Mom’s More Likely To Skip Circumcision? - [...] come from a small town, where most people I know did not breastfeed, and many of them also chose …

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current month ye@r day *